The Magic or Impossible Triangle

You're probably familiar with the Penrose triangle, an impossible object that can't exist in ordinary 3D space, and the Kanizsa triangle, an illusion that makes a triangular shape appear thanks to carefully-placed fragments. Now Christopher Tyler from the Smith-Kettlewell Institute in San Francisco has creatively combined the two brain tricks in an animation to produce a dual effect.

In the video above, the inner markings of an impossible triangle appear first. With the twirl of an animated magic wand, you start to see the full shape as the spinning stick induces illusory contours.

Then three red spheres appear, reminiscent of the circles in Kanizsa's famous trick, moving across the screen in different ways to infer contours once again. Finally, the balls settle into the corners of the triangle, superimposing the two classic illusions and creating the most pronounced combination of the two effects.

According to Tyler, depth processing, which occurs in the occipital lobe of the brain, helps us perceive the impossible triangle. Since the shape displays conflicting orientations, our brain picks one of these possible realities and switches between them. The triangle at the end of the video appears thanks to illusory contours, which are created as our brain choosees the most likely configuration given the visual information provided.

The illusion was short-listed at the Best Illusion of the Year Contest which took place last week in Naples, Florida. You can see the other winning illusions here.

Floating Dice: Optical Illusions

It may seem like an impossible construction. In this video, stacked-up dice seem to float on top of each other. They even appear to hover when viewed up close, until a hand appears on camera to reveal the visual trick. Were you fooled by the illusion?

This set-up, recreated by illusion fanatic Rex Young, is a classic devised by legendary illusionist Jerry Andrus. You may be familiar with the effect as it's one example of the hollow mask illusion.

When viewing a concave mask, most people perceive a convex face. It's our brain's most common interpretation of the visual information since we're so used to seeing people's everted faces.

The late British psychologist Richard Gregory studied the illusion and saw it as evidence for the top-down processing of visual information. Interestingly, a recent study found that people with schizophrenia are immune to the effect, raising the possibility that the illusion could be used as a diagnostic tool.

The dice arrangement was one of our favourite illustrations of this illusion, but we came across a lot of other examples. Have you seen a version of the effect that you find particularly effective? Let us know in the comments below.

Optical Illusions - Camels in the night

Click on the picture to view more optical illusions

Colour Blindness in Motion

A new illusion shows how our perception of objects changes as soon as they start moving.

At first, the ring of dots is motionless and it's easy to tell that the dots are changing color. When the ring begins to rotate, however, the dots suddenly appear to stop changing.

The faster the ring moves, the less the colours appear to change. But in reality, they were changing the whole time, at the same rate. As the video shows, the illusion also works for brightness, shape and size.

The phenomenon - change blindness - by which observers don't notice that an image is changing in front of their eyes, isn't new.

Nor is the notion that motion affects the way we see objects - watch our video special on moving illusions for lots of other cool examples - this new illusion designed by Jordan Sochow and George Alvarez at Harvard University demonstrates the principle especially well.

The pair believe the illusion occurs because the areas of the retina responsible for detecting these changes are local - each part of the visual field is monitored by a specific part of the retina. Because a fast moving object spends little time at any one location, a local detector only has a small window of time in which to assess the changing object - and therefore fails to detect the change. 

Journal Reference: Current Biology, DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2010.12.019

Optical Illusions

Checker shadow and other Illusions

1. CHECKER SHADOW

Although it may seem impossible to believe, the squares marked 'A' and 'B' are actually exactly the same shade of grey 

This amazing illusion was created by Edward H Adelson from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Although it may seem impossible to believe, the squares marked 'A' and 'B' are actually exactly the same shade of grey! 

Your eyes and brain are constantly trying to figure out the colour of the objects around you, and in doing so automatically compensate for shadows. 

The square marked 'B' is in the shadow cast by the green cylinder, while the square marked 'A' is outside of the shadow. 'Hold on - if a square in a shadow reflects the same amount of light as a square outside of the shadow, then in reality it must be a much lighter shade of grey.' As a result, your brain alters your perception of the image so that you see what it thinks is out there in the real world.

2. GRID

As you move your eyes around the image, dark dots quickly appear and disappear at the intersections.

However, whenever you look directly on any intersection, the dark dots vanish

The original version of this illusion was first reported by German physiologist Ludimar Hermann in 1870, and simply involves a white grid on a black background. 

For years it was widely believed that the illusion worked because of 'lateral inhibition' - the term used to describe the complex way in which the cells on the back of the retina respond to areas of black and white. 

There is, however, little point in explaining the theory. Why? Because a few years ago it was shown to be completely untrue, and thus the explanation for the illusion remains a mystery.

3. THATCHER

 

 

This upside-down photograph of ex-Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher looks perfectly normal. However, when you rotate the photograph the right way up the face will appear grotesque, thus proving that 'the lady's not for turning'. The grotesque face is due to the eyes and mouth being inverted. But why don't you spot this when the photograph is upside down?

There are specific parts of your brain dedicated to face perception. However, because you rarely encounter upside-down faces, these parts of your brain work best with upright faces. When presented with an upside-down face, your brain is able to identify the different parts of the face, such as the eyes and mouth, but unable to perceive the relationship between these parts; hence it doesn't spot the distorted face.

4. TABLETOPS

In this classic illusion, the two tabletops look completely different shapes but are actually identical

 The illusion works for two reasons. First, vertical lines tend to look relatively long while horizontal lines tend to look relatively short. 

Also, the legs induce a sense of perspective, causing the back of the tabletop on the left to appear to be much further away than the back of the tabletop on the right. Your brain alters your perception of the tabletops, making the left one appear completely different to the right one.

5. CAFE WALL

The horizontal lines in this image appear to be sloping, but in reality they're parallel to one another. Why does it work? 

Although it's easy to see the mortar line between two black tiles or two white tiles, it's much harder to see the mortar line between a white tile and a black one. 

Your brain fills in the gap by seeing it as part of either a white or black tile. This, in turn, makes the tiles look wider at one end than at the other, creating the illusion of a series of wedge-shaped tiles, which makes the lines appear to slant.

6. LEANING TOWERS

These two photographs of the Leaning Tower of Pisa are identical, yet the tower on the right appears to lean more than the tower on the left. 

Created by Frederick Kingdom and colleagues from McGill University in Montreal, the illusion works because your eyes and brain treat the two photographs as if they're part of a single scene. 

If the two towers really were next to one another and rising at the same angle, they'd appear to converge due to perspective. So when your eyes and brain see two towers that are parallel, they assume that they must be diverging as they rise into the air, and thus create the resulting illusion. 

Each year the Neural Correlate Society holds the Best Illusion of the Year Contest to find new and wonderful illusions. The Leaning Tower illusion won the contest in 2007.

7. EINSTEIN

This amazing image looks like physicist Albert Einstein. However, move a few feet away from the screen and suddenly it'll transform into Marilyn Monroe. The work of Aude Oliva and her colleagues at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, the illusion was created in three steps.

First, the researchers obtained a photograph of Marilyn Monroe and removed the fine-grained facial features, such as any wrinkles or other blemishes.

Second, they obtained a photograph of Albert Einstein and removed the more coarse features, such as the shape of the mouth or nose.

Finally, the two images were superimposed on top of one another. Because the fine-grained features are visible close up, the image looks like Albert Einstein when you're just a few inches away from the page. 

However, move a few feet away and suddenly only the coarse features are visible, magically transforming the image into Marilyn Monroe.

8. DUCK-RABBIT

When you first look at this picture you'll probably see a rabbit facing to the right. 

However, if you continue to look at the picture it'll flip to become a duck looking to the left. 

This is known as a 'bistable' image. You won't be able to see both pictures at the same time and will instead flip between seeing the duck and then the rabbit. 

This illusion was originally popularised in 1899 by American psychologist Joseph Jastrow, who used it to make the point that we 'see' with our brains as well as our eyes.

9. ROTATING SNAKES

Although the coils in the image appear to be rotating, in reality they're completely stationary. 

The effect works best in peripheral vision, so when you stare at one of the coils it will appear stationary while those around it will appear to rotate. 

This wonderful illusion was created by Japanese psychologist Akiyoshi Kitaoka from Ritsumeikan University in Kyoto. Vision experts aren't exactly certain why it works; however, their research has revealed that the shading of the segments that make up the rings is crucial. 

These segments are arranged in a repetitive pattern consisting of a relatively dark area (yellow) followed by a brighter one (white), then a less bright one (blue), and finally the darkest area (black). 

Information from high-contrast parts of the image (yellow-white, white-blue and blue-black) travels to the brain faster than that from low-contrast parts (blue-black). It's believed that this 'staggered' information mimics the type of input that the eyes and brain receive when they see genuine motion, and so you end up believing that you're looking at actual movement.

10. IMPOSSIBLE TRIANGLE

The dice appear to form an impossible triangle. Your eyes and brain are fooled because they assume that all of the corners of the triangle are touching one another. 

In reality, the photograph has been taken from a very specific angle. 

If the position of the camera was to shift slightly, you would see that in reality the 'triangle' is actually created by three lines of dice arranged in the shape of the letter 'Z'. 

As such, one of the 'corners' in the photograph actually consists of two ends that are a very long way apart. This idea is based on a drawing of an impossible triangle originally created by physicist Roger Penrose in 1954.